The Aztecs and Toltecs were two of the major civilizations that dominated central Mexico prior to the Spanish conquest in the early 16th century. They shared similarities in culture, religion, and language, which has led some people to think they were the same civilization. However, there were also key differences between the Aztecs and Toltecs in their origins, political systems, art and architecture, and ultimate fate. Examining the history of both groups sheds light on whether they can accurately be considered one and the same.
Origins and Rise to Power
The Toltecs were the earlier of the two great civilizations, developing their empire in the Valley of Mexico beginning around 900-1000 CE. Their capital was the city of Tula, located about 40 miles northwest of what would later become Mexico City. According to Aztec legends, the Toltecs descended from a tribe called the Chichimecs who migrated to central Mexico around this time. The Toltecs grew wealthy through trade and tribute, and came to culturally and politically dominate the region.
In contrast, the Mexica people who would become the Aztecs arrived in the Valley of Mexico much later, around 1250 CE, as part of the last wave of the Nahuatl-speaking peoples who migrated into central Mexico from the north. Lacking a homeland, they served as mercenaries to various city-states in the valley until they founded their own city, Tenochtitlan, around 1325 CE on an island in Lake Texcoco. From this strategic location they slowly grew and consolidated their power through alliances and conquest.
While the Aztecs credited the earlier Toltecs with establishing the foundations of civilization in the region, the two groups had distinct origins in terms of their ancestral homelands and their rise to power in the Valley of Mexico.
The Toltec civilization was centered around the city of Tula, which likely exercised political and economic control over nearby areas through a mixture of military might and trade relationships. However, our limited knowledge of the Toltecs makes it hard to determine the exact nature of their political system. There is no evidence they established an extensive empire or subjected other groups to direct Toltec rule.
In contrast, the Aztecs created a robust tribute empire that subjected neighboring city-states and peoples to their political will. Key reforms early in Aztec history created a dual power structure of the tlatoani (emperor) working with the Council of Four to lead the city-state. This system allowed for orderly succession and effective administration of a rapidly growing empire. At its height in the early 1500s, the Aztecs directly controlled much of central and southern Mexico.
So while the Toltecs influenced later cultures like the Aztecs through advances in urban living, trade, architecture, and religion, they did not build an empire or develop a bureaucracy on the level of the Aztecs. The Aztec’s complex political system enabled them to administer their vast holdings for over a century.
Religion and Gods
Both the Toltecs and Aztecs practiced polytheistic religions focused on nature gods, although the Aztecs adopted and modified Toltec beliefs to suit their own needs. The Toltecs worshipped Quetzalcoatl as a creator god and cultural hero. Quetzalcoatl was seen as bringing enlightenment through knowledge and arts to humanity. Other important Toltec gods included the rain god Tlaloc and the god of darkness, Tezcatlipoca.
The Aztecs adopted aspects of the Toltec pantheon but elevated their tribal god Huitzilopochtli into the role of supreme ruler of the gods. Quetzalcoatl, Tlaloc, and Tezcatlipoca were also worshipped but were subordinate to Huitzilopochtli. The Aztecs practiced ritual human sacrifice on a massive scale as offerings to the gods, especially Huitzilopochtli, whereas evidence of large-scale human sacrifice among the Toltecs is more limited.
So the Aztecs borrowed and adapted Toltec beliefs to their needs, with an emphasis on appeasing their patron god Huitzilopochtli through blood offerings. This sets them apart from the earlier Toltecs who do not seem to have practiced human sacrifice in such quantities.
Art and Architecture
The Toltecs had their capital at Tula, sometimes known as Tollan, which remained a revered city in Aztec lore and pilgrimage long after its abandonment. Tula was centrally planned around temples, palaces, and plazas. The architectural style featured sculpted, feathered serpents and columns in the form of bundled reeds. The Toltecs were also known for their expressive artworks emphasizing humans and nature, including the famous Atlantes figures supporting a platform at Tula.
Aztec architecture borrowed Toltec features like pyramid-temples, colonnaded halls, and stylized feathered serpents. The dual temple-pyramids in their capital Tenochtitlan were dedicated to Tlaloc and Huitzilopochtli in clear echo of the main temple at Tula devoted to Quetzalcoatl. However, the scale and intricacy of Aztec buildings far surpassed Toltec works. Aztec art also used Toltec motifs but developed a more abstract and geometric style. The Aztecs excelled at lapidary work, feather-working, and goldsmithing.
So the Aztecs adopted a similar architectural grammar and artistic styles but executed them on a grander scale with imperial resources, creating awe-inspiring cities like Tenochtitlan. Toltec art, while incorporating some abstract motifs, remained comparatively more naturalistic.
Both the Toltecs and Aztecs spoke forms of the Nahuatl language. Nahuatl was the dominant language of central Mexico and continued to be used across Mesoamerica until the Spanish Conquest. The Toltecs spoke a variant of Nahuatl that likely influenced later dialects. However, few Toltec-era inscriptions remain to shed light on their exact language. Aztec Nahuatl is much better documented in codices and oral accounts written down after the conquest. The abundance of speakers allowed Nahuatl to remain the common language of central Mexico throughout shifts in political control from Teotihuacan to the Toltecs to the Aztecs as the lingua franca of trade and diplomacy.
The Fall of Tula and Tenochtitlan
The causes of Tollan/Tula’s demise around 1150 CE remain disputed. A popular legend holds that Quetzalcoatl was driven out by Tezcatlipoca, leading to the city’s abandonment, but this may be mythologized history. Ecological factors like deforestation and drought may have undermined Tula’s agricultural base. Internal political conflicts and outside invasion have also been proposed. Whatever the exact causes, overpopulation and resource depletion seem to have played a role. After Tula, no single power dominated central Mexico for over a century.
The Aztec capital of Tenochtitlan met its doom through outside conquest by the Spanish and their native allies in 1521 CE. Its immense size and fierce resistance to the last doomed the once powerful city. Following Cortes’ victory, Tenochtitlan was systematically razed and a new Spanish colonial capital built atop its ruins. So the Aztec capital endured a violent and definitive end, rapidly replaced by a new cultural order. Tula, in contrast, was gradually abandoned and left to crumble over decades, with its former glory persisting in legend.
While the Aztecs inherited and emulated aspects of Toltec culture, religion, architecture, and language, there were fundamental differences between these two towering civilizations of ancient Mexico. The Toltecs were the forerunners who created a cultural template later adopted by the Aztecs, but the two groups had distinct origins, political systems, and fates. The Aztecs also practiced ritual bloodletting and human sacrifice on a scale not seen among the Toltecs. Toltec art and architecture, though stylistically influential, was surpassed in scale by the wealth and imperial ambition of the Aztecs. So while the Aztecs venerated the Toltecs and modeled themselves on Toltec antecedents in many ways, they forged their own unique and formidable empire that would dominate Mesoamerica until the arrival of Cortes. The answer to whether Toltecs and Aztecs were the same civilization is ultimately no, although the Aztecs represented a kind of second flourishing influenced by the earlier achievements of the Toltecs.
Smith, Michael E. “Life in the Provinces of the Aztec Empire.” Scientific American, vol. 277, no. 3, 1997, pp. 76-83.
Townsend, Richard F. The Aztecs. 3rd ed., Thames & Hudson, 2009.
Carrasco, Davíd. The Aztecs: A Very Short Introduction. Oxford University Press, 2012.
Matos Moctezuma, Eduardo. The Great Temple of the Aztecs: Treasures of Tenochtitlan. Thames & Hudson, 2012.
Whittington, E. Michael. The Sport of Life and Death: The Mesoamerican Ballgame. Thames & Hudson, 2001.
Soustelle, Jacques. Daily Life of the Aztecs on the Eve of the Spanish Conquest. Stanford University Press, 1961.
Berdan, Frances F. The Aztecs of Central Mexico: An Imperial Society. Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1982.
Coe, Michael D. Mexico: From the Olmecs to the Aztecs. 7th ed., Thames & Hudson, 2013.
Additional Details and Analysis
The Aztecs and Toltecs have often been conflated or confused with each other. But despite similarities stemming from the Aztecs’ adoption of Toltec models, they were distinct civilizations that rose and fell at different times. Here are some additional details on key differences between these two influential Mesoamerican cultures:
Government – As noted, the extent and structure of Toltec political control remains hazy with no evidence of an organized empire. Aztec rule was highly centralized and hierarchical, with the tlatoani wielding absolute authority sanctioned by divine right. The Aztec legal system was also highly codified, using previous court cases as precedents. Toltec governmental institutions remain obscure by comparison.
Economy – Trade and tribute sustained both civilizations, but the scale achieved under Aztec rule has no Toltec parallel. Cocoa beans, cotton, salt, and slaves were circulated over vast distances. Markets at Tenochtitlan were far larger and more varied than any Toltec antecedent. Jade and exotic bird feathers traveled from distant Maya regions to Tenochtitlan.
Warfare – Both engaged in regular, ritualized warfare aimed at obtaining tribute and captives for sacrifice. Flower Wars were fought by the Aztecs as a means of honorable combat to demonstrate valor and capture victims. But Aztec imperialism and militarism massively exceeded any Toltec precedents in scale and systematization. Military orders and advanced weapons like the macuahuitl distinguished Aztec armies.
Sacrifice – Both practiced human sacrifice, but the sheer scope of Aztec ritual killing—involving the dedicated sacrifice of thousands of victims annually during key ceremonies—far exceeded Toltec antecedents in its pervasiveness and cultural centrality. The massive Round Pyramid at Tenochtitlan was specifically designed around this bloody ritual function.
Art – Toltec art was primarily oriented toward naturalistic depictions of humans, animals, and plants. Aztec art built on Toltec themes but developed a more abstract and schematic aesthetic valuing geometric precision. The Aztec sun stone, for example, exemplifies their highly stylized iconography. Toltec art motifs notably lack militaristic themes so prevalent in Aztec works.
Science/Calendars – Both had advanced knowledge of astronomy and calendars to regulate agricultural cycles. The Aztecs modified the existing Toltec calendar to better suit their mythic history and worldview. Their dual calendar system of a 260-day ritual cycle interlocked with a 365-day solar year was an innovation enabling exact scheduling of rites, ceremonies, and divination.
So while the Aztecs borrowed and expanded on Toltec models in many spheres, from urban planning to religion, they ultimately created a more stratified, warlike, and ritualistic society that systematically exploited their empire to feed their gods and capital city on an unprecedented scale in Mesoamerica. Their cultural connection and debts to the Toltecs are clear, but the differences are equally pronounced.
In investigating the relationship between the Toltecs and Aztecs, it is clear they cannot be equated as the same civilization. While adopting elements of Toltec culture, the Aztecs had their own distinct identity and achievements. They absorbed Toltec traditions but took them to new extremes, building the largest and most fearsome empire ever seen in the New World before the arrival of the Spanish. Toltec precedents shaped Aztec religion, art, architecture, and urbanism, but Aztec civilization took these foundations and transformed them by the force of arms into something unprecedented that still awes with its bloody audacity. The Toltecs were a formative influence, but the Aztecs supplanted them by crafting their own unique culture and empire. They appreciated their Toltec forebearers, yet they ultimately built something that stood apart in Mesoamerican history for its imperial reach and martial excesses. In summary, the Aztecs adopted Toltec antecedents but wove them into a civilization all their own.